Doorgaan naar hoofdcontent

An orchestral democracy

A fully grown democracy is actually comparable to a good functioning orchestra.

We had a nice discussion tonight about palestine and it's religious side. Which does not allow for too much secular individuality but at the same time garantuees a civil harmony you don't find in any western state.

In an orchestra, for example the orchestra we have now for beethoven 9th symphony. We have choir and orchestra. Where the choir, the 4 voice groups are actually like 4 big instruments that sometimes play together and sometimes individual, is composed of singers that need to function together in perfect harmony like in an organised religion.

In front of the choir the orchestra is composed of the winds and brass, wo need to carry a lot of individuality to be able to play solo parts. Acousticly they carry a big responsability, because errors are very easily heard.

The same goes for percussion. The strings are somewhat similair to the choir. A part from section leaders.
They also breath and play like one.

So you can see that a lot of individuality, of a secular quality needs to be guaranteed to be able to have a functioning orchestra.
The same goes for a state. Although one religion maybe most important, the integrity of the individual should be garantueed (woodwinds/brass/section leaders). Of course without that the fabric of society (choir/strings) falls apart.

The most healthy situation is where section leaders rotate, and where the conductor changes frequently. So the power stays with the people, and doesnt go only to the leader.

The democratic institutions that allow for this rotation, division of power and secularity should balance with the religious and cultural fabric that binds the people together. Then there can be harmony!

Reacties

Populaire posts van deze blog

The orchestra and the Clash of civilizations

After being held like a little child by the beautiful palestinian people and their culture. I am back in the western world. As soon as you cross the checkpoint, you enter the west again. Feelingwise, here you don't constantly greet people. Here there's a different level of hygiene. Here people are more in the heads and less in their bellies. In Palestine children are everywhere on the street, here it is quiet. You could say the ageold conflict of jerusalem is culturally going on. Although in a different jacket with a different story. Like samuel huntington's clash of civilizations describes. In Jeruzalem you can feel it. Crossing the checkpoint you can feel the muscle of the israeli's. It is similair to our european borders, if you don't have the right passport. They make you feel that you have less rights by being palestinian, you have to make an extra mile by stepping out of the vehicle and walking trough the checkpoint. Today i got the conduct the woodw...

The frontiers of my tolerance

The frontiers of my own tolerance. Being here in Palestine, hearing the stories of their suppression is difficult. Especially when you are hosted like a foreign king. You can see them struggle with the occupation, and the emotions with the fact their land, culture and property is under pressure. It is under pressure by israel, and mostly the religious orthodox streams of power that claim on dubious historical research that they were once the inhabitants. At the same time there is a clash of culture. In a mostly muslim run society, you respect the leader does not matter what happens. He is the leader of the clan, but one should not compare this to democracy! There are no checks and balances. It is another style of leadership and control. More based on the belly. Maybe one can vote, but there are no mature institutions that can protect the individual as we know it. I met someone from Turkey today who works in a culture center and who came here in Ramallah to give funding to a...

Crocodile tears, or how unexpressed pain eats your human decency

It has been i week now i left the middle east, sailing on the Ostsee, near to the place i was born has given me some space inside to work my impressions of the conflict area. Especially difficult for me to see my israeli friends suffer from emotions of pain and self-pity, because they are leftist israeli’s. This means that even the most intelligent and cultured israeli’s are not seeing really what their country is doing. Although i don’t oppose the fact that jews should have a place in the world where they can live and be safe from anti-semitism, i do oppose zionistic colonialism as it is expressed now in the west bank. So i will tell you my final impressions of the palestine trip: On my last day i went to friends in Israel to make a reflection of my experiences in Palestine. Arriving tired, dirty and hungry, they took care of me and made me ready for my travel trough the highly secured Ben Gurion Airport. Which is an experience in itself… Anyway, at th...